Overall Quality of “Early” Potato Tubers as Affected by Organic Cultivation

Understanding the nature of the perceived quality advantage of organically-grown early crop potatoes over conventionally-grown ones is of relevance given the expansion in demand for foodstuffs produced by environmentally friendly agricultural practices. The effect of the cultivation system (organic vs. conventional) on physicochemical (skin color, firmness, skin thickness, pH, titratable acidity), nutritional (dry matter, ascorbic acid, total phenolics content, antioxidant activity), and sensorial (for boiled and fried tubers) traits of early potatoes were explored in a field trial conducted during two-seasons in Sicily (Southern Italy) and involving five yellow-fleshed genotypes. The organic cultivation system, averaged across seasons and genotypes, produced tubers displaying a more attractive skin color, with higher skin thickness and firmness, higher dry matter content (19.0 vs. 17.9%), and total phenolics content (350 vs. 232 mg GAE 100 g⁻¹ dry weight) but lower ascorbic acid content (76 vs. 103 mg 100 g⁻¹ dry weight) and antioxidant activity (42 vs. 56% DPPH reduction). The organic cultivation did not affect attributes after boiling but improved all sensory attributes (crispness, typical taste, and browning degree) after frying, highlighting that the superiority of the organic potatoes does not cover all aspects of quality. The positive effects of organic cultivation on physicochemical, nutritional, and sensorial quality were particularly evident in Arinda, Ditta, and ISCI 4F88. Even if the response of organic cultivation on overall quality also depended upon seasonal conditions, cultivar choice plays a key role in optimizing this production system, highlighting the importance of breeding programs.