Variation in body size and trophic morphology within and among genetically differentiated populations of the cichlid fish, Metriaclima zebra, from Lake Malawi

1. The cichlid fish Metriaclima zebra, common in Lake Malawi, feeds by filtering plankton from the water and by brushing items from sediment covered substrata. It inhabits isolated rocky reefs among which community structure, resource availability and gene pools are likely to differ. We speculated that body size and trophic morphology of M. zebra might vary concomitantly. 2. We quantified the extent of genetic, body size and trophic variation within and between populations of M. zebra from southern Lake Malawi. Specifically, we tested the hypotheses that: (i) local populations are genetically differentiated, (ii) local populations differ in jaw morphology, dentition and standard length (SL), and (iii) variation in size is correlated with variation in trophic morphology. 3. Local populations of M. zebra differed in mean SL and were genetically differentiated. Moreover, populations exhibited dissimilar oral jaw morphologies and dentitions, perhaps related to differences in feeding biology. Variation in jaw shape was largely restricted to the curvature of the distal tip of the dentary. Populations were characterised by individuals with oblique, upward or downward directed gapes. Dental patterns differed in the proportion of unicuspid teeth in all rows of each jaw (dentaries and premaxillae) and the spacing of teeth in affected rows. 4. Within populations, jaw and tooth shapes were correlated with body size. Smaller individuals possessed upward curving jaws and closely packed multicusped teeth, while larger individuals exhibited relatively downward-directed jaws with increasing numbers of widely spaced unicuspid teeth. 5. Metriaclima zebra populations have increased in mean SL over the last decade, in contrast to a decline among Lake Malawi pelagic cichlids. Differences in size may contribute to variation in trophic morphology and may track local environmental dynamics in this lacustrine system.