Evaluation of the CAMS reanalysis for atmospheric black carbon and carbon monoxide over the north China plain

Black carbon (BC) and carbon monoxide (CO) at different model levels from the Copernicus Atmosphere Monitoring Service (CAMS) reanalysis were comprehensively evaluated against observations performed simultaneously on both surface and mountain sites in winter and summer in the North China Plain for the first time. CAMS could capture the seasonal difference in BC and CO emission on both sites but showed significant and persistent biases. Biases were high on the surface site and low on the mountain site for both seasons, implying the uncertainties in emission inventories used in the CAMS reanalysis which may have more influence near source. Biases were reduced and the correlation coefficient of CAMS BC with observed BC increased when two datasets were compared on a daily basis, which suggests daily or longer time averaged CAMS BC could be more suitable for trend analysis. Although CAMS could generally reproduce the distinct diurnal variation of BC and CO on both sites, the inaccurate representation of the daily evolution of planetary boundary layer (PBL) in model may bring more uncertainties to the concentration biases on surface from midnight to early morning. BC hydrophilic ratio from CAMS displayed large biases compared to observations with no seasonal difference on both sites, which was probably resulted from the initial emission state of BC hygroscopicity for all source types in model. Uncertainties in the removal processes and the simplified aging processes in model could further induce uncertainty in modelling BC hydrophilic ratio in the CAMS. These results could not only be referenced for the improvement on CAMS reanalysis but also facilitate model or trend analysis of BC and CO pollution by utilizing the CAMS reanalysis product from both short- and long-term perspectives, which will be beneficial to both the mitigation and policy-making on primary emissions in China.