Is anticipatory governance opening up or closing down future possibilities? Findings from diverse contexts in the Global South
2023
Muiderman, Karlijn | Vervoort, Joost | Gupta, Aarti | Norbert-Munns, Rathana Peou | Veeger, Marieke | Muzammil, Maliha | Driessen, Peter
There is an urgent need to understand how anticipation processes such as scenario planning impact governance choices in the present. However, little empirical research has been done to analyze how anticipation processes frame possibilities for action. This paper investigates how assumptions about the future open up or close down anticipatory governance actions in a large number of climate-focused anticipation processes. We focused on four Global South regions: West Africa, South Asia, Southeast Asia and Central America. We apply an analytical framework that identifies four diverse approaches to anticipatory governance and connect this to the notion of opening up or closing down of possibility spaces for action. Across the four regions, we find that many anticipation processes open up dialogue about deep uncertainties and pluralistic worldviews but end up informing mostly technocratic and linear planning actions in the present. We also observe that anticipation processes in the Central American context more often break this trend, particularly when transformative ambitions are formulated. The focus on more technocratic futures and linear planning strategies and reliance on a mostly North-based global futures industry may close down more culturally, socially and politically diverse and regionally relevant future worldviews in anticipation processes.
Show more [+] Less [-]Bibliographic information
This bibliographic record has been provided by Wageningen University & Research