Effect of ionic strength on the Mg content of calcite: Toward a physical basis for minor element uptake during step growth

This experimental study determined the effect of ionic strength (IS) on the uptake of Mg into calcites that grew by the classical step propagation process. Using flow-through AFM and defined solution chemistry, calcite was grown in NaCl and KCl solutions of known supersaturation state while measuring the corresponding growth kinetics. Analysis of the resulting calcite compositions by SIMS shows that Mg content is inversely correlated with IS for both electrolytes. A sixfold increase in IS decreases the Mg-content by up to 40%. Overgrowths that developed in NaCl solutions contain more Mg than samples that grew in KCl solutions. The corresponding kinetic measurements reveal that step propagation rates are independent of IS within experimental error but are electrolyte-specific. In NaCl solutions, steps with the obtuse geometry move significantly faster than acute steps, but in KCl solutions, the acute and obtuse steps move at similar rates. Analysis of the data suggests that the decrease in Mg content with increasing IS arises from the interplay of ion–kink interactions between the background cations (Na⁺ or K⁺), the primary solute cation (Ca²⁺), and the impurity (Mg²⁺). A simple physical model proposes that increasing levels of electrolytes block the attachment of the strongly hydrated Mg²⁺ ion relative to Ca²⁺ but the effects are step-specific for each type of electrolyte. Whereas K⁺ interacts weakly with kink sites along both step directions, Na⁺ interacts preferentially with acute steps and, consequently, slows their rate of step propagation relative to obtuse steps. Because Na⁺ increases the fraction of the surface that develops from acute steps and because Mg is preferentially incorporated into the kink sites of acute steps, calcite overgrowths developed in NaCl solutions contain more Mg than those in grown in KCl. Thus, the salt-specific Mg contents measured in this study can be explained by shifts in the distribution of step types and the ability of each step type to incorporate Mg. The findings reconcile apparent discrepancies regarding the effect of IS on calcite kinetics and Mg incorporation observed in laboratory-based studies.