Effects of natural organic matter on the joint toxicity and accumulation of Cu nanoparticles and ZnO nanoparticles in Daphnia magna

Various modern products have metallic nanoparticles (MNPs) embedded to enhance products performance. Technological advances enable nowadays even multiple hybrid nanoparticles. Consequently, the future co-release of multiple MNPs will inevitably result in the presence of MNP mixtures in the environment. An important question is if the responses of mixtures of MNPs can be dealt with in a similar way as with the responses of biota to mixtures of metal salts. Moreover, natural organic matter (NOM) is an important parameter affecting the behavior and effect of MNPs. Herein, we determined the joint toxicity and accumulation of copper nanoparticles (CuNPs) and zinc oxide nanoparticles (ZnONPs) in Daphnia magna in the absence and presence of Suwannee River natural organic matter (SR-NOM), compared to the joint toxicity and accumulation of corresponding metal salts. The results of toxicity testing showed that the joint toxicity of CuNPs + ZnONPs was greater than the single toxicity of CuNPs or ZnONPs. The joint toxic action of CuNPs + ZnONPs was additive or more-than-additive for D. magna. A similar pattern was found in the toxicity of the mixtures of Cu- and Zn-salts from the literature data. The presence of SR-NOM had no significant impact on the joint toxicity of CuNPs + ZnONPs. The calculated component-specific contribution to overall toxicity indicated that SR-NOM increased the relative contribution of dissolved ions released from the MNPs to the toxicity of the binary mixtures at high-effect concentrations of individual MNPs. Moreover, dissolved Zn-ions released from the ZnONPs were found to dominate the joint toxicity of CuNPs + ZnONPs in the presence of SR-NOM. Furthermore, the results of the accumulation experiment displayed that the presence of SR-NOM significantly enhanced the accumulation of either CuNPs or ZnONPs in D. magna exposed to the MNP mixtures.