Comparison of Phosphorus Concentrations in Coastal Plain Watersheds Served by Onsite Wastewater Treatment Systems and a Municipal Sewer Treatment System

Eutrophication related to excess phosphorus (P) loadings continues to be an important issue for watersheds in North Carolina and other regions. Identifying the contributing sources of P in nutrient-sensitive waters is important for improving water quality. Prior studies have indicated that onsite wastewater treatment systems (OWS) can be a contributing source of P to surface waters, but more information is needed regarding their contribution relative to other wastewater treatment technologies. The goal of this study was to determine if P concentrations in groundwater and surface water were significantly different in a coastal plain watershed served by OWS in comparison to a watershed served by a municipal sewer system (MWS). Groundwater P concentrations were monitored at ten residential sites (five5 OWS and five MWS) once during each season (four times), and stream P concentrations and watershed exports were monitored monthly for 1 year (August 2011–August 2012). Groundwater in the OWS watershed had higher P concentrations than the MWS watershed. Stream P concentrations and P exports were also elevated in the OWS watersheds. However, the OWS were more efficient at reducing P prior to surface water discharge than the wastewater treatment plant that served the MWS watershed. The site-scale and watershed-scale P treatment efficiencies of OWS were between 73 and 99 %, whereas P treatment efficiency for the wastewater treatment plant was 54 %. While the OWS were efficient at reducing P concentrations and loads, OWS were still significant sources of P exports from the studied watershed. Potential contributions of P from OWS should be included in watershed nutrient management strategies along with other known sources such as agriculture and urban runoff if the strategies are to be considered comprehensive.