Population genetic characteristics of two crucian carp varieties derived from distant hybridization

The Hefang crucian carp (HFJ) derived from Carassius cuvieri (♀) × C. auratus red var. (♂) and the crucian carp-like homodiploid fish (NCRC) derived from Cyprinus carpio (♀) × Megalobrama amblycephala (♂) are important germplasm resources of crucian carp. To investigate the population characteristics and reveal the current genetic situations of these hybrid varieties, we sequenced one nuclear molecular marker transferrin (Tf) among six Carassius populations, which included two hybrid varieties (HFJ and NCRC), one laboratory variety (red crucian carp, RCC) and three wild populations. A total of 166 distinct Tf alleles (A1∼A166) were identified, with sequence lengths ranging from 1145 bp to 1244 bp. Unexpectedly, the nucleotide diversity of Tf alleles in cultured populations (HFJ, NCRC, and RCC) exceeded that of wild populations. The phylogenetic reconstruction analysis results showed that HFJ and C. cuvieri were closely related, but they could not be separated from C. auratus. Besides, while most Tf alleles of NCRC and other Carassius populations were intermixed in five clades, two Tf alleles, together with Cy. carpio, formed a distinct monophyletic clade. Moreover, network and genetic structure analyses failed to distinguish between wild and cultured populations. Although AMOVA analysis based on Tf alleles indicated genetic differentiation among all six populations, the majority of the genetic variation (92.00 %) was observed within populations. Furthermore, the population dynamics analysis suggested that these populations have maintained relative stability in recent history. Therefore, the elevated nucleotide diversity of Tf alleles in cultured populations, the ambiguous population structure, and the limited genetic divergence among the six Carassius populations highlighted the hybrid genetic characteristics of HFJ and NCRC. These findings, based on Tf alleles, differ from the results obtained using mitochondrial gene markers, providing an alternative perspective for germplasm evaluation of hybrid varieties and crucian carp breeding.