Trophic relationships of juvenile blue crabs (Callinectes sapidus) in estuarine habitats

Salt marshes and shallow-water macroalgal beds are known to provide nursery habitat for many species of fish and invertebrates. The role of these habitats as refuge from predation is well established, but the degree to which indigenous primary production within the nursery provides food for growth and development of estuarine species remains unresolved. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that juvenile blue crabs depend on indigenous primary production, directly or indirectly, during their entire stay within the nursery. To test this hypothesis, we conducted isotopic studies and stomach content analyses of juveniles from habitats near the mouth of Delaware Bay and from an adjacent lagoonal estuary (ca. 39.5° N, 75.1° W). Primary producers, marsh detritus, various life-history stages of blue crabs and potential prey species were sampled in the main estuary and in an adjacent marsh during the summer and early fall of two consecutive years. Newly settled juveniles (<15 mm carapace width) from the marsh were about 1.8‰ lighter in carbon (−17.2‰) relative to larger juveniles from the marsh (15–30 mm carapace width) and appeared to have retained a carbon isotopic signature indicative of the phytoplankton-based food web associated with larval stages. However, the signature of juveniles changed as a function of size. Large juveniles and crabs >60 mm were enriched in δ¹³C (−14.7 ± 0.1‰) compared to small crabs, suggesting a gradual shift in diet from a planktonic to a detritus-based food web with increasing size. As with crabs from Delaware Bay, the δ¹³C signature of juvenile crabs sampled from macroalgal beds in the lagoonal estuary (Rehoboth Bay) changed as a function of size. Also, δ¹³C ratios of crabs varied among the various species of macroalgae. The δ¹⁵N composition of primary producers in the marsh and main estuary also was reflected in the δ¹⁵N values of crabs and other benthic consumers in the respective habitats. Results of stomach-content analysis in this study were consistent with isotope data. Observed changes in prey preferences were related to changes in size of juvenile crabs and also differed among habitats. Gut content analyses of the three size classes of juveniles in macroalgal beds from Rehoboth Bay indicated that the crabs depend heavily on various amphipod species that occur on the seaweeds. These amphipods graze directly on the macroalgae and are among the most abundant invertebrates in the macroalgal beds. This implies a direct trophic relationship between the juvenile crabs and the macroalgae. In summary, our study provides strong evidence that the value of nursery areas such as salt marshes and macroalgal beds goes beyond that of providing refuge from predation, and that species using these nurseries (e.g. juvenile blue crabs) are ultimately dependent on primary production originating in benthic plants indigenous to the nursery.