Effects of composted pulp and paper industry wastewater treatment residuals on soil properties and cereal yield

The aim of this study was to investigate effects of pulp and paper industry wastewater treatment sludge composts on soil and cereal crops. Five forest industry wastewater sludge composts were tested in a field study which was conducted in a silty clay soil in southern Finland with barley in 1998, with oats in 1999 and with barley in 2000. Two composts contained only pulp mill biosludge and bark in a ratio of 1:4 and 1:2, respectively. Two other composts were mixtures of biosludge and primary sludge with the addition of bark in a ratio of 1:2 and 3:4, respectively. These two wastewater sludges originated from a pulp mill and from a recycled paper mill. The fifth compost consisted of biosludge and primary sludge from a board mill. Two application rates of each compost were studied: the low rate was based on an annual P fertilization rate recommended for barley, 50-200 m(3) /ha; and the high rate was a double or triple the low rate depending on the mineral N concentration of the compost, 150-600 m(3) /ha. Based on the Finnish fertilizer recommendations, nutrient demands of the test plants were annually fulfilled by mineral fertilizers depending on the treatment. Total contents of N, P, K and Ca in composts were 8.8-17.5, 0.7-3.9, 1.5-6.5, and 4-25 g/kg dry matter, respectively. Especially at high doses, composts had beneficial effects on soil bulk density, porosity, C and N contents and C:N ratio. Despite the high total N rates applied with the composts, the mineralization following crop harvest did not significantly increase soil nitrate late autumn or following spring as compared to the soils that received mineral fertilization. There was no significant difference in the grain yields between plots that received mineral fertilization and compost treatments supplemented with mineral fertilizers. However, there was a decreased fertilization effect of some composts on straw yields during the first experimental year, indicating immobilization of mineral N. Heavy metals added in soil with the composts did not significantly increase their concentrations in the grain crops. All the composts had relatively low nutrient contents and low fertilizing value, but beneficial effects on soil properties and were regarded as soil conditioners. Soil improving and fertilizing effects of the composts varied annually depending on the weather conditions during the growing season. Heavy metal concentrations of the composts studied were far below the limit values set for the soil conditioners in the Finnish government regulations.