Determination of trans octadecenoic acids by silver-ion chromatography-gas liquid chromatography: an intercomparison of methods

Several silver-ion chromatography-gas liquid chromatography (GLC) techniques for the determination of trans octadecenoic acids in partially hydrogenated vegetable fats were collaboratively evaluated. Twelve laboratories participated in the study. All collaborators used high polarity fused silica capillary columns for the separation of fatty acid methyl esters by GLC; 7 collaborators isolated trans monoenes by silver-ion liquid chromatography (Ag-LC) and the remainder used silver-ion thin-layer chromatography (Ag-TLC). Eight artificially prepared materials [soybean oil spiked with either methyl elaidate, trielaidin, or trans octadecenoates isolated from partially hydrogenated sunflower oil (PHSO)] and 2 matrix materials (PHSO and a blend of PHSO and palm oil) served as test samples. Ag-TLC and Ag-LC proved to be equivalent techniques for the prefractionation of trans monoenes. Recovery of methyl elaidate, trielaidin, or trans octadecenoates isolated from PHSO varied between 97.9-103.7% over a concentration range of 1 to 30 g trans fatty acids/100 g. Reproducibility relative standard deviation (RSD(R)) for the spiked samples were in the range of 3.1-8.6% for 30-1% trans monoene content. For the 2 matrix samples (mean 3.75 and 19.08% trans monoene content) RSD(R) was 13.2 and 3.6%. The hyphenated techniques tested proved to be highly accurate and sufficiently precise methods for the determination of trans monoenes in partially hydrogenated vegetable fats. Procedural variations of the silver-ion chromatography prefractionation step (separation mode, mobile phase, and detection systems) did not significantly influence the results of the test. Therefore, silver-ion chromatography is a robust method, which does not need rigorous standardization to achieve high precision of test results. A further benefit of the hyphenated technique is that any type of efficient polar capillary column can be used.