Species admixture can increase potential tree growth and reduce competition

Trees often show better growth in mixed as opposed to monospecific neighborhoods as consequence of competition reduction and facilitation between species. However, it can be challenging to discern the effect of these factors as they occur simultaneously, so often they are jointly refereed as complementarity. By using tree growth models based on potential tree growth reduced by a competition modifier and including species mixing effects on both components (potential tree growth and competition modifier), we aim to verify that tree potential growth is modified by admixture, which may provide further information on species interactions and complementarity. We used tree data from the Spanish National Forest Inventory, selecting plots located in two different mixtures, Scots pine – European beech and Scots pine – Oak mixtures, as well as in the corresponding monospecific stands of those species. To analyse whether the species mixture increases the potential basal area growth, we developed linear mixed quantile regressions to model the potential growth, while to analyse the competition reduction we developed linear mixed models. We include the Martonne aridity index as a measure of the site conditions in the models to explore whether climate conditions modify the effects of species mixture. Our results show a slight effect of the mixture on the potential basal area growth of pine while the potential growth of beech clearly benefited from the pine/beech mixtures. For the pine/oak mixtures the potential growth of both species was higher in mixtures than in monospecific stands. Moreover, we found a positive influence of humidity on potential growth for all the species and mixtures, although the magnitude of the effect was less important for beech and more notable in the case of the pine/oak mixtures. We also found that for the studied species, admixed species reduced competition, with lower inter-specific than intra-specific competition effects, and that these effects were mediated by climate conditions. We concluded that the potential tree basal area growth is influenced by the species admixture, which suggest that species mixing effects can be relevant also under low stand densities. Our results highlight the importance of integrating the effect of species interactions on both the potential growth of trees and the competition modifier when the aim of the research is to further our understanding of species interactions.