Response of Terrestrial Net Primary Production to Quadrupled CO₂ Forcing: A Comparison between the CAS-ESM2 and CMIP6 Models

Terrestrial net primary production (NPP) is a key carbon flux that changes with rising atmospheric CO₂ and CO₂-induced climate change. Earth system models are commonly used to investigate these NPP changes because of their fundamentally trustworthy ability to simulate physical climate systems and terrestrial biogeochemical processes. However, many uncertainties remain in projecting NPP responses, due to their complex processes and divergent model characteristics. This study estimated NPP responses to elevated CO₂ and CO₂-induced climate change using the Chinese Academy of Sciences Earth System Model version 2 (CAS-ESM2), as well as 22 CMIP6 models. Based on CMIP6 pre-industrial and abruptly quadrupled CO₂ experiments, the analysis focused on a comparison of the CAS-ESM2 with the multi-model ensemble (MME), and on a detection of underlying causes of their differences. We found that all of the models showed an overall enhancement in NPP, and that CAS-ESM2 projected a slightly weaker NPP enhancement than MME. This weaker NPP enhancement was the net result of much weaker NPP enhancement over the tropics, and a little stronger NPP enhancement over northern high latitudes. We further report that these differences in NPP responses between the CAS-ESM2 and MME resulted from their different behaviors in simulating NPP trends with modeling time, and are attributed to their different projections of CO₂-induced climatic anomalies and different climate sensitivities. These results are favorable for understanding and further improving the performance of the CAS-ESM2 in projecting the terrestrial carbon cycle, and point towards a need for greater understanding and improvements for both physical climatic processes and the terrestrial carbon cycle.