Challenges of genetic homogeneity in aquaculture of the kelp Saccharina japonica: Insights from China in ten year’s retrospect

Genetic homogeneity among principal cultivars of the kelp Saccharina japonica was first documented a decade ago in Rongcheng, a historically significant Saccharina farming city in China. Seven large-scale hatcheries in this region supply seedlings for approximately 50,795 ha of cultivation area, yielding ∼2.7 million metric tons of fresh biomass annually. These hatcheries have implemented independent breeding programs to enhance the productivity of cultivated populations. To assess decadal changes in farmed populations, we conducted a comprehensive investigation during the 2023–2024 cultivation cycle, combining microsatellite marker analysis of genetic composition/structure with open-sea cultivation trials to evaluate both genotypic and phenotypic characteristics. Our analyses confirmed persistent genetic homogeneity in five of six examined cultivars, consistent with prior findings. Standardized parental sporophyte selection criteria, coupled with uniform hatchery protocols and infrastructure, were identified as primary drivers of homogeneity. Notably, genetic introgression was detected in 2024 populations following the introduction of a hybrid cultivar developed through targeted hybridization at one hatchery. The incorporation of phylogenetically distinct germplasm induced measurable genotypic and phenotypic modifications in farmed populations, concomitant with productivity improvements. These findings underscore the necessity for hatcheries to maintain self-sustaining broodstock management and seedling production systems to preserve cultivar genetic integrity in a multi-hatchery operation environment. Regular monitoring of population genetic architecture is strongly recommended to ensure sustainable aquaculture practices.