An enantioselective study of the behavior of the herbicide ethofumesate in agricultural soils: Impact of the addition of organoclays and biochar

Chiral pesticides that are still commercialized and incorporated into the environment as racemic mixtures of enantiomers require evaluation of the enantioselectivity of their biological activity and environmental fate processes for a better prediction of their field efficacy and environmental risks. In this work, we successfully separated the enantiomers of the chiral herbicide ethofumesate (ETFM), determined their absolute configuration, and characterized their herbicidal activity as well as their adsorption, degradation, enantiomerization, and leaching in Mediterranean agricultural soils. While the herbicidal activity of R-ethofumesate to the sensitive species Portulaca grandiflora was greater than that of S-ethofumesate, the adsorption, degradation, and leaching of the herbicide showed negligible enantioselectivity and enantiomer interconversion did not occur in soils. The adsorption of both enantiomers showed a positive correlation with the soil organic carbon content (r = 0.856, P = 0.015), and their degradation in soils occurred slowly (DT50 > 60 days) and at similar rates independent of their application as individual enantiomers or as a racemic mixture of enantiomers. The addition of three highly adsorptive materials to a scarcely adsorptive soil increased the adsorption of the enantiomers of ETFM and delayed their degradation without affecting the non-enantioselective character of the processes. As a result of their high adsorption capacity, the materials were highly effective in reducing the leaching of both enantiomers of ETFM through soil columns. The results of this work indicate that the application of single-enantiomer ETFM formulations, based on a higher herbicidal activity or a lower toxicity to non-target organisms of the formulated enantiomer, would reduce considerable exposure risks associated with incorporating into the environment the less favorable enantiomer, as this would show long persistence and high leaching potential in soils similar to its optical isomer.