Variation in Soil Methane Release or Uptake Responses to Biochar Amendment: A Separate Meta-analysis
2018
Ji, Cheng | Jin, Yaguo | Li, Chen | Chen, Jie | Kong, Delei | Yu, Kai | Liu, Shuwei | Zou, Jianwen
Agricultural soils play an important role in the atmospheric methane (CH₄) budget, where paddy soils can contribute significant CH₄ to atmosphere whereas upland soils may act as a source or sink of atmospheric CH₄, dependent on soil water conditions. Biochar amendments have effects on soil CH₄ production or oxidation processes in individual experiments, but the causative mechanisms are yet to be fully elucidated. To synthesize the response of soil CH₄ release or uptake to biochar amendment, we performed a meta-analysis using data from 61 peer-reviewed papers with 222 updated paired measurements. When averaged across all studies, biochar amendment significantly decreased CH₄ release rates by 12% for paddy soils and 72% for upland soils, and CH₄ uptake rates by 84% for upland soils. Neither soil CH₄ release nor uptake responses to biochar amendment were significant in field soils. Nitrogen (N) fertilizer application would weaken the response of soil CH₄ release or uptake to biochar amendment. Biochar-incurred decreases in soil CH₄ release and uptake rates were the largest in medium-textured soils or neutral-pH soils. Soil CH₄ release or uptake responses to biochar were also significantly altered by biochar characteristics, such as feedstock source, C/N ratio, pH, and pyrolysis temperature. The results of this synthesis suggest that the role of biochar in soil CH₄ mitigation potential might have been exaggerated, particularly in fields when biochar is applied in combination with N fertilizer.
显示更多 [+] 显示较少 [-]