Labile soil organic carbon, soil fertility, and crop productivity as influenced by manure and mineral fertilizers in the tropics

In recent years, organic agriculture has been receiving greater attention because of the various problems like deterioration in soil health and environmental quality under conventional chemical-intensive agriculture. However, little information is available on the comparative study related to the impact of use of mineral fertilizers and organic manures on the soil quality and productivity. A long-term field experiment was initiated in 2001 to monitor some of the important soil-quality parameters and productivity under soybean-wheat crop rotation. The treatments consisted of 0, 30, and 45 kg N ha⁻¹ for soybean and of 0, 120, and 180 kg N ha⁻¹ for wheat. The entire amount of N was supplied to both the crops through urea and farmyard manure (FYM) alone or in combination at 1:1 ratio. Results indicated that Walkley-and-Black C (WBC; chromic acid-oxidizable) exhibited a marginal increase under only organic treatments as compared to control treatment (without fertilizers and manure) after completion of five cropping cycles. In case of labile-C (KMnO₄-oxidizable) content in soil, relatively larger positive changes were recorded under organic, mixed inputs (integrated) and mineral fertilizers as compared to WBC. Maximum improvement in the values of C-management index (CMI), a measure of soil quality was recorded under organic (348-362), followed by mixed inputs (268-322) and mineral fertilizers (198-199) as compared to the control treatment after completion of five cropping cycles. Similarly there was a substantial increase in KCl-extractable N; in Olsen-P; as well as in DTPA-extractable Zn, Fe, and Mn under organic treatments. Although labile soil C positively contributed to the available N, P, K, Zn, Fe, and Mn contents in soil, it did not show any relationship with the grain yield of wheat. After completion of the sixth cropping cycle, organic treatments produced 23% and 39% lower grain yield of wheat as compared to that under urea-treated plots. Relatively higher amount of mineral N in soil at critical growth stages and elevated N content in plant under mineral-fertilizer treatments compared to FYM treatments were responsible for higher yield of wheat under mineral fertilizers.