Consideration of metabolomics and transcriptomics data in the context of using avian embryos for toxicity testing
2022
Legrand, Elena | Jeon, Yeon-Seon | Basu, Niladri | Hecker, Markus | Crump, Doug | Xia, Jianguo | Chandramouli, Bharat | Butler, Heather | Head, Jessica
Early-life stage (ELS) avian toxicity tests have been proposed as a more ethical alternative to traditional standardized tests with adult birds. At the same time, 'omics approaches are gaining traction in the field of avian toxicology, but little has been done to characterize the metabolome and transcriptome at different life stages. The present study uses 'omics data from toxicity tests of 8 environmental chemicals in ELS and adult Japanese quail (Coturnix japonica) to address this data gap. Previous analyses of these data focused on responses to each of the individual chemicals. Here, we consider data from all studies to describe variation in the metabolome and transcriptome between life stages and across independent experiments, irrespective of chemical treatment. Of the 230 metabolites detected in liver, 163 were shared between the two life stages. However, many of the targeted bile acids that were present in the adult liver were absent from ELS samples. For the transcriptome, >90% of the 18,364 detected transcripts were common to both life stages. Based on the 213 genes solely detected in ELS liver, the neuroactive ligand-receptor interaction pathway was significantly enriched. Multivariate and hierarchical clustering analyses revealed that variability among independent experiments was higher for the adult than the ELS studies at both the metabolomic and transcriptomic levels. Our results indicate concordance of the two approaches, with less variation between independent experiments in the ELS metabolome and transcriptome than in adults, lending support for the use of ELS as an alternative toxicity testing strategy.
显示更多 [+] 显示较少 [-]