Time shifts in height and diameter growth allocation in understory European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) following canopy release

KEY MESSAGE: In understory trees, height–diameter allocation is subject several constraints: maximal height growth is limited, height growth is never null and, in terms of time dependency, diameter growth always precedes height growth. Understory trees experience a succession of canopy opening and closure events during their lifetime. Preferential allocation of their biomass to height or diameter growth is part of the acclimation process to their immediate environment. In this study, we investigated annual height and diameter increments in Fagus sylvatica understory trees submitted to canopy release. Annual height and diameter increments were obtained from retrospective stem analysis from the top of the tree to the stump on 39 understory trees. The relationship between height and diameter increments was investigated and temporal correlations among successive annual height and diameter increments were analyzed. An asymptotic relationship between annual height and diameter increment indicates that stem height growth was limited in understory trees. The intercept significantly differed from zero suggesting that height growth never stopped even when diameter growth was null. Following canopy release events, immediate diameter growth increase was observed while the height growth response was delayed, resulting in a time shift in the growth allocation strategy. Strong and asymmetric temporal correlations between annual height and diameter increments were observed: past annual diameter growth was positively correlated to present height growth. In understory trees, tree height is the main factor determining their potential growth since it determines their access to above-canopy light. However, the precedence of diameter growth over height growth suggests that tree growth is driven by diameter instead of height. This apparent discrepancy may be explained by the fact that, under closed canopy conditions, stem allometry reaches a functional threshold that forces tree to grow in diameter before growing in height.