The importance of ammonia volatilization in estimating the efficacy of nitrification inhibitors to reduce N2O emissions: A global meta-analysis

Nitrification inhibitors (NIs) have been shown to be an effective tool to mitigate direct N₂O emissions from soils. However, emerging findings suggest that NIs may increase soil ammonia (NH₃) volatilization and, subsequently, indirect N₂O emission. A quantitative synthesis is lacking to evaluate how NIs may affect NH₃ volatilization and the overall N₂O emissions under different environmental conditions. In this meta-analysis, we quantified the responses of NH₃ volatilization to NI application with 234 observations from 89 individual studies and analysed the role of experimental method, soil properties, fertilizer/NI type, fertilizer application rate and land use type as explanatory factors. Furthermore, using data sets where soil NH₃ emission and N₂O emission were measured simultaneously, we re-evaluated the effect of NI on overall N₂O emissions including indirect N₂O emission from NH₃ volatilization. We found that, on average, NIs increased NH₃ volatilization by 35.7% (95% CI: 25.7–46.7%) and increased indirect N₂O emission from NH₃ emission (and subsequent N deposition) by 2.9%–15.2%. Responses of NH₃ volatilization mainly varied with experimental method, soil pH, NI type and fertilizer type. The increase of NH₃ volatilization following NI application showed a positive correlation with soil pH (R² = 0.04, n = 234, P < 0.05) and N fertilizer rate (R² = 0.04, n = 187, P < 0.05). When the indirect N₂O emission was considered, NI’s N₂O mitigation effect decreased from 48.0% to 39.7% (EF = 1%), or 28.2% (EF = 5%). The results indicate that using DMPP with ammonium-based fertilizer in low pH, high SOC soils would have a lower risk for increasing NH₃ volatilization than using DCD and nitrapyrin with urea in high pH, lower SOC soil. Furthermore, reducing N application rate may help to improve NIs’ overall N₂O emission mitigation efficiency and minimize their impact on NH₃ volatilization.