Antler Allometry, the Irish Elk and Gould Revisited | Antler Allometry, the Irish Elk and Gould Revisited
2024
Tsuboi, Masahito | Kopperud, Bjørn Tore | Matschiner, Michael | Grabowski, Mark Walter | Syrowatka, Christine | Pelabon, Christophe | Hansen, Thomas Fredrik
The huge antlers of the extinct Irish elk have invited evolutionary speculation since Darwin. In the 1970s, Stephen Jay Gould presented the first extensive data on antler size in the Irish elk and combined these with comparative data from other deer to test the hypothesis that the gigantic antlers were the outcome of a positive allometry that constrained large-bodied deer to have proportionally even larger antlers. He concluded that the Irish elk had antlers as predicted for its size and interpreted this within his emerging framework of developmental constraints as an explanatory factor in evolution. Here we reanalyze antler allometry based on new morphometric data for 57 taxa of the family Cervidae. We also present a new phylogeny for the Cervidae, which we use for comparative analyses. In contrast to Gould, we find that the antlers of Irish elk were larger than predicted from the allometry within the true deer, Cervini, as analyzed by Gould, but follow the allometry across Cervidae as a whole. After dissecting the discrepancy, we reject the allometric-constraint hypothesis because, contrary to Gould, we find no similarity between static and evolutionary allometries, and because we document extensive non-allometric evolution of antler size across the Cervidae.
显示更多 [+] 显示较少 [-]publishedVersion
显示更多 [+] 显示较少 [-]