Efficacy of Nano-Phytobiotics to Improve Growth Performance of Broiler Chickens: Evidence from a Meta-Analysis

Faizal Andri; Nanung Danar Dono; Heru Sasongko; Zuprizal Zuprizal

Efficacy of Nano-Phytobiotics to Improve Growth Performance of Broiler Chickens: Evidence from a Meta-Analysis

2021

Faizal Andri | Nanung Danar Dono | Heru Sasongko | Zuprizal Zuprizal

The ban of antibiotic growth promoters in many countries necessitate the need for alternatives. This study aimed to assess the growth-promoting potency of nano-phytobiotics (NP) on broiler chickens by using a meta-analysis approach. A systematic search was conducted using online databases. Data of average daily feed intake (ADFI), average daily gain (ADG), and feed conversion ratio (FCR) were pooled using a random-effect model and the overall effect size was quantified using mean difference (MD). Heterogeneity among the studies was checked using I2 statistics. A total of 11 studies (31 comparisons) using 3,584 broiler chickens were involved in this meta-analysis. Inclusion of NP had no significant effect on ADFI (MD=-1.20 g/bird/d; P=0.157; I2=32%). However, NP significantly improved ADG (MD=2.16 g/bird/d; P=0.002; I2=90%) and FCR (MD=-0.09; P<0.001; I2=91%). Subgroup analysis revealed that NP significantly improved (P<0.05) ADG when the studies using dose of 45-200 and 1,000-10,000 ppm, as well as 42 d study period. Meta-regression analysis also indicated that ADG improvement significantly associated (P<0.05) with the NP dose and study duration, which could explain 21% and 20% of heterogeneity, respectively. This meta-analysis provides evidence that NP inclusion could improve ADG and FCR without alter ADFI on broiler chickens. However, their efficacy may vary according to the NP dose and study duration.

Показать больше [+]