A comparison study of test organism species and methodologies for combined toxicity assay of copper ions and zinc ions

He, Jingting; Ma, Shuaining; Liu, Ling; Liu, Chang; Dong, Shaojun

A comparison study of test organism species and methodologies for combined toxicity assay of copper ions and zinc ions

2020

He, Jingting | Ma, Shuaining | Liu, Ling | Liu, Chang | Dong, Shaojun

The general toxicity assays for evaluating the risk of aquatic environment were commonly based on single-species test organism models. Thus, the lack and conflict of the different responses among species had hindered researchers to assess the real toxicity of a target toxicant. Therefore, the difference between the test species and their corresponding methodologies was investigated in this work and three species, Escherichia coli, Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Misgurnus anguillicaudatus (a fish), were chosen as the test organism for typical prokaryotes, eukaryotes, and vertebrates, respectively. More specifically, we investigated (i) the individual and combined toxicity of Cu²⁺ and Zn²⁺ by the three test organisms; (ii) the different evaluation manners for the test organisms, including IC₅₀ and toxic unit (TU) model for microorganisms by respiratory toxicity assay and enzyme-substrate assay, while survival time for fish; and (iii) the states of test organism, including suspended and immobilized states for microorganisms. The combined effects, including synergistic (Vt < Vp), antagonistic (Vt > Vp) and additive effects for the three species, were complex as that they were usually dose-dependent and could be changed by the different evaluation manners. The present work was useful for enriching of the associated theory and the insights from this work could open the way for further practical risk assessments.

Показать больше [+]